Why Nobody Smiles in Old Photographs
Why Nobody Smiles in Old Photographs: A Deeper Look into the History of Photography and Human Expression
When we glance at old photographs, a curious pattern often emerges: people rarely smile. In the digital age, where every social media feed is filled with beaming faces, this historical absence of smiles stands out, leaving us wondering, “Why didn’t people smile in old photographs?” Many myths have circulated about this—ranging from dental hygiene to cultural norms—but the real reasons are more complex and fascinating than commonly thought. This article will take you on a journey through the technological, cultural, and social evolution that explains this phenomenon.
1. The Role of Early Photography Technology
One of the primary reasons behind the lack of smiles in old photographs has to do with the nature of early photography technology. In the 19th century, taking a photograph was a lengthy process, especially with the popular daguerreotype process, which was one of the earliest forms of photography.
The daguerreotype method, named after its inventor Louis Daguerre in 1839, was a complex and time-consuming process. Each photograph had to be exposed for several minutes, often ranging from five to 15 minutes, depending on the light conditions. As you might imagine, holding a smile for that long was not only uncomfortable but unnatural. Maintaining a neutral expression was far easier and more sustainable for long exposure times.
Additionally, early cameras required a large amount of light to produce a clear image. The long exposure time meant that even a slight movement, such as twitching from holding a smile, could result in a blurry image. Therefore, subjects were advised to remain still and adopt a serious expression to avoid ruining the photo. In many cases, photographers even used head clamps or supports to help individuals maintain their posture during the photograph.
It wasn’t until the advent of faster exposure times in the late 19th century, with technological advances like the Kodak Brownie camera introduced in 1900, that photography became quicker and more accessible. However, by then, the cultural habit of posing seriously had been deeply ingrained.
Why Nobody Smiles in Old Photographs
2. Social and Cultural Expectations of Portraiture
Beyond the technical limitations, cultural norms of the 19th century played an equally significant role in why people didn’t smile in photographs. To understand this, we need to look at the broader history of portraiture.
Before photography, most people could only afford to have their portrait painted by an artist, and such portraits were often a luxury reserved for the wealthy and powerful. The practice of portraiture followed strict conventions; subjects were expected to project an image of dignity, authority, and formality. This trend carried over when photography began to replace traditional portrait painting as the preferred method of immortalizing oneself or one’s family.
At the time, smiling was not associated with formality or seriousness. Instead, it was often seen as something connected to foolishness, intoxication, or triviality. Portraiture, whether painted or photographed, was a serious affair meant to project the respectability and status of the individual or family. As a result, smiling would have been considered out of place in such an important moment of self-representation.
Furthermore, many of the earliest photographs were taken to commemorate important life events, such as marriages, graduations, or, most notably, death. Victorian-era mourning customs included the practice of post-mortem photography, in which recently deceased individuals were photographed in lifelike poses as a way for families to remember them. Naturally, the somber nature of these photographs did not lend itself to smiling subjects.
3. The Perception of Smiling in Society
Smiling, as we understand it today, was not always considered a positive social signal. In the 19th and early 20th centuries, an open smile was often associated with childishness or mental instability. The idea of maintaining a reserved and controlled demeanor was a reflection of the societal values of the time. People valued stoicism, dignity, and a sense of restraint, especially in public spaces.
This view of smiling was not exclusive to Western cultures; many other societies around the world shared similar perceptions. In Japan, for example, Honne and Tatemae (personal feelings versus public facade) emphasize the importance of maintaining a neutral or serious demeanor in public, while smiles and laughter are reserved for private settings or moments of genuine joy.
The American historian Christina Kotchemidova has explored this in her research, arguing that the concept of smiling in photos as a social norm only began to shift in the early 20th century. By then, the rise of leisure activities, urbanization, and a growing consumer culture began associating smiles with happiness, positivity, and success. In this sense, smiling in photographs became tied to broader societal changes that reflected the development of a more optimistic and casual worldview.
4. The Impact of Professional Photography Studios
The rise of professional photography studios in the 19th century further shaped how people posed for pictures. Photography was still a luxury for many, and having your portrait taken was considered a significant event. People often saved up money to have professional portraits done, and these photos were often intended to last a lifetime. As a result, individuals wanted to ensure that their image was as formal and dignified as possible, contributing to the serious expressions seen in old photographs.
In contrast to today’s casual “selfie” culture, where photos are taken frequently and with little forethought, 19th-century subjects approached photography with a sense of gravity. Many of these portraits were intended to be passed down through generations, and people wanted to ensure that they were portrayed in a manner that reflected well on them. The notion of “leaving a legacy” played a major role in how people presented themselves for these photographs, reinforcing the preference for serious expressions.
Why Nobody Smiles in Old Photographs
5. The Evolution of Photography: From Serious to Smile
As photography became more widespread and the technology advanced, societal attitudes toward photography and portraiture began to change. By the early 20th century, cameras were becoming more affordable, and the process of taking a photograph had become faster and less formal. The invention of smaller, portable cameras like the Kodak Brownie allowed for candid snapshots that captured moments of everyday life.
This democratization of photography led to a shift in how people posed for photographs. Smiling became more common as photography evolved from a formal and costly endeavor to an accessible and spontaneous activity. This change was partly due to advertising campaigns launched by companies like Kodak, which emphasized the joy of capturing happy memories. Kodak’s slogan “You press the button, we do the rest” encouraged people to take photos at family gatherings, vacations, and celebrations—moments when smiles naturally occurred.
In addition, the rise of Hollywood cinema in the early 20th century played a significant role in popularizing the idea of smiling. Movie stars, with their charismatic and glamorous personas, began to shape cultural norms around appearance and behavior. Smiling became associated with friendliness, confidence, and attractiveness, qualities that were increasingly desired in the modern age of mass media and consumerism.
6. The Rise of Dentistry and Oral Hygiene
Another factor that contributed to the rise of smiling in photographs was the improvement of dental care. In the 19th century, dental hygiene was not as advanced as it is today, and many people suffered from bad teeth, which they were often reluctant to display. Dental problems such as missing, crooked, or discolored teeth were common, particularly among the working class, and this might explain why many people preferred to keep their mouths closed in photographs.
The early 20th century saw major advancements in dentistry, including the development of modern toothbrushes, toothpaste, and dental treatments. As oral hygiene improved, people became more comfortable with showing their teeth in public and in photographs. The invention of orthodontics and cosmetic dentistry also contributed to a more aesthetically pleasing smile, making smiling a more socially acceptable and even desirable expression in photography.
7. The Influence of Psychology and Positive Emotions
As photography became more ingrained in daily life, psychology began to explore the power of facial expressions, particularly smiles, in conveying emotions and influencing social interactions. Researchers like Paul Ekman in the late 20th century studied how facial expressions communicate universal human emotions, including happiness, anger, fear, and sadness. This research confirmed that smiles are universally understood as a signal of happiness and friendliness.
In a broader context, the rise of psychology as a field of study in the 20th century led to an increasing focus on positive emotions and their impact on mental and physical well-being. By the mid-20th century, smiling had become an important social tool for fostering connections and relationships. Whether in personal photos, professional portraits, or advertising campaigns, smiles were encouraged as a way to communicate warmth, openness, and approachability.
8. The Legacy of Smiling in Modern Photography
Today, smiling in photographs is not just a cultural norm; it is expected. With the advent of smartphones and social media platforms like Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok, the number of photographs taken daily has skyrocketed. People are constantly curating and sharing their lives through images, and smiling has become a way to convey positivity and happiness.
However, the history of photography serves as a reminder that smiling in photos is a relatively recent development, shaped by technological advancements, cultural shifts, and social norms. From the solemn portraits of the Victorian era to the candid, joyful snapshots of today, the way we express ourselves in photographs continues to evolve.
More Than Just a Smile
The absence of smiles in old photographs is a window into the past—a reflection of the technological, cultural, and social realities of the time. What was once seen as a serious and dignified expression has given way to the cheerful, carefree smiles we associate with photography today. Understanding the reasons
Why Nobody Smiles in Old Photographs
AP COLLECTION “I AM LOVE” Premium Unisex Crewneck T-shirt * It’s a Good Day (ardelles.com)
Comments